I know I'm not the only person in this class who is a fan of
cult classics, and one of my first obsessions as a young theatrical
practitioner (read: music theatre obsessed teenager) was Rocky Horror. Everyone
in their late teen years looks for an excuse to wear too much makeup and
fishnets, right? ...Right?
I digress. So. My best friend from high school, who has been
working nationally and on Broadway for the last few years, and incidentally who
introduced me to Rocky Horror, made a pit stop this year in our incredibly
progressive (read: conservative and controlled by the Koch Brothers and Sam
Brownback) city of Wichita, KS to do the live production of Rocky Horror as the
choreographer and to play the role of Rocky. Generally speaking, this wasn't a
big deal, and the population was actually really excited for the show to be
staged in Wichita for the first time in years, and Mo has a pretty big presence
in town for his influence as a choreographer and the work he did before he
moved, so there was a pretty supportive vibe from the locals for the production.
The thing is, is that Maurice is black. Again, this shouldn't be an issue,
because there's nothing in the script that notes Rocky having a specific race,
and when the show is about transvestite aliens and has like, no plot line, who
is to say that casting a black actor in that role is revolutionary,
right?
Well, the Wichita Eagle (local newpaper) thought otherwise.
Their promotion of the show put emphasis on Maurice playing Rocky by saying
"Actor-choreographer Sims says that being the first black Rocky Horror –
certainly locally and likely nationally – won’t change the dynamic of the
plot."
When I talked to Mo about it, I asked him what he thought of
the interview with the paper. He said something along the lines of "he was
trying to make a big deal out of it and get me to say things about the role
like I was so proud to be given the opportunity to play Rocky and I was
like...It's not a big deal, I'm sure I'm not the first black guy to do it. I
mean, it's about sex and aliens, how weird does it have to be?" In the
article, he's quoted much more eloquently, responding to the question with "it
will actually add depth to the show by supporting the idea that Rocky is
different from everybody else,” Sims said. “He has a man’s body, but he is a
new creature, so he has the mind of a baby. He is experiencing the world for
the first time.” That is all to say that while I don't necessarily agree that this was a brave choice for color-blind casting, the overall success of the show was not altered or affected negatively in any way by this choice. I thought the show was a delight, he did a fantastic job, and nothing about casting a black actor took me out of the experience.
On the other hand, there are a lot of issues I have with the adaptation of Annie 2014 to film. First of all, modernizing the script- um, what?- and trying to update it so it isn't deadly theatre and inaccessible to a modern audience- nice try, it sucks regardless- but with a show that is arguably "iconic" in the music theatre community, with a signature cartoon and red wig, an old, bald white guy, and a crippled president to be forced into the 21st century and race swapped for a black orphan and black tycoon have already raised a lot of eyebrows from fans. I will eat crow if it does work, but thus far, I'm having a hard time buying into the swap in this instance.